Property

Image extracted from submitted plans. See full documents in the attachments section below.

DRB23-0958

428 South Hibiscus Drive

The following summaries were generated by AI from the official documents linked below. They may contain errors. Please refer to the original documents for authoritative information.

Proposal

The applicant is proposing to construct a second floor addition to an existing 2-story home by demolishing a portion of an existing wall and sliding glass door to expand the second floor bedroom approximately 8'-3½" westward. The proposal requires variances from the maximum lot coverage and maximum unit size requirements.

From the Letter of Intent

The Applicant proposes to renovate and add a small amount of livable area to the center of the second-floor of the existing single-family home. This includes renovating an existing study into a bedroom with a full bathroom and enclosing the attached balcony facing the waterway, with a modest addition of 128 square feet of living space.

  • Renovate existing study at center of rear of second floor into bedroom with full bathroom
  • Enclose attached balcony facing the waterway
  • Construct 128 square feet addition of living space on second floor
  • Maintain existing balcony railing with no changes to sides or roof of home
Staff Recommendation
DENIAL

Compliance Findings:

✗ Sea Level Rise: Not Satisfied ✗ Variance Conditions: Not Satisfied ✗ Design Review Criteria: Not Satisfied
Key Issues
  • Variance request for lot coverage exceeding 30% maximum (proposing 31.8%)
  • Variance request for unit size exceeding 50% maximum (proposing 55.1%)
  • Staff finds variance requests do not satisfy hardship criteria
  • Concerns about setting precedent for similar increases on other single family properties
  • Missing lighting plan submission
Project Details
Style Contemporary style
Height 27'-4" (2-story)
Zoning RS-3
Lot Size 19,932 SF
Applicant Casa Alaia LLC
Architect Madison Worth Architecture, DPC
Existing Building
Year Built 1936
Style Contemporary style
Stories 2
Demolition proposed
Meeting

Tuesday, February 6, 2024

View Full Agenda